cocktaildna

New York City, United States

Brooklyn

The Brooklyn is a rye-driven, spirit-forward cocktail with a bitter-sweet edge from dry vermouth and maraschino, finished with a hit of Amer Picon.

bitterspirit-forwardryeamarocherryherbaldrystirredpre-prohibitionorange bitters

%

ABV

Difficulty

Brooklyn

Overview

What this drink is like

The first sip is dry and spicy from the rye, with a faint cherry sweetness lurking underneath. Mid-palate, the dry vermouth and Amer Picon pull things toward bitter and herbal. The finish is lean and warming, with a lingering bitter-orange note that sticks around.

Who will like it

For people who like bitter-sweet, spirit-forward drinks with a dry finish and herbal depth.

When to drink

A solid before-dinner drink or a late-night sipper when you want something short and bracing.

Ordering tip

Ask for Amer Picon specifically — many bars default to a different amaro, which shifts the flavor away from the classic profile.

Ice: NoneTemp: ColdCost: $3–$6Glass: CoupeBatch-friendlyMake ahead

Flavor

Taste profile

The Brooklyn hits you with rye spice and bitter orange right away, then a faint cherry sweetness surfaces before the drink dries out again. It's lean and warming, with no citrus or cream to soften the edges. The herbal, bitter finish hangs on for a while. Think of it as a Manhattan's drier, more bitter cousin that swapped sweet vermouth for dry and brought along some strange friends.

Finish: The finish runs long and dry, with bitter orange and herbal notes lingering after the rye warmth fades.

Primary tastes

bitterherbalsweet

Secondary

earthynutty

Aroma

cherrybitter orangerye spicedried herbs
  • Bitternessnoticeably bitter

    The Amer Picon and dry vermouth give a firm bitter backbone that sits front and center.

  • Sweetnessmoderately sweet

    The maraschino adds a touch of sweetness but the dry vermouth and amaro keep it in check.

  • Strengthstrong

    Rye makes up the bulk of the drink, and the low dilution from stirring keeps it potent.

  • Refreshingwarming and lean

    This is a sipping drink meant to be taken slowly, not a thirst-quencher.

  • Complexitylayered

    Rye spice, cherry, bitter orange, and herbal notes all show up at different points in the sip.

Recipe

Make it at home

Stirred · Coupe · equal parts on Rye Whiskey. A spicy, high-rye bourbon or straight rye works best

Before you start

Put your coupe glass in the freezer for a few minutes if you can. Grab fresh ice for the mixing glass — big cubes chill with less dilution.

Ingredients

  • Rye WhiskeyBase SpiritA spicy, high-rye bourbon or straight rye works best45ml
  • Dry VermouthVermouth25ml
  • Maraschino LiqueurLiqueurLuxardo is the standard10ml
  • Amer PiconLiqueurTorani Amer is the common US substitute10ml

Garnish: Maraschino cherry

Tools

  • Mixing glass · Mixing

    To combine and chill the ingredients with ice while stirring

    At home: A large pint glass or any tall, wide glass

  • Bar spoon · Mixing

    To stir the drink smoothly and evenly

    At home: A long-handled spoon or chopstick

  • Jigger · Measuring

    To measure the ingredients accurately

    At home: A measuring shot glass or tablespoon

  • Hawthorne strainer · Straining

    To strain the ice out when pouring the drink into the glass

    At home: A small fine-mesh sieve

  • Coupe glass · Serving

    To serve the drink chilled and stem-held

    At home: A small wine glass or martini glass

Steps

  1. 1

    Measure 45ml rye whiskey, 25ml dry vermouth, 10ml maraschino liqueur, and 10ml Amer Picon into the mixing glass. Pour them right in — no particular order matters.

    !Pouring heavy-handed with the maraschino or Amer Picon will make the drink cloying or overly bitter.

  2. 2

    Fill the mixing glass about three-quarters full with ice. The ice should sit above the liquid so everything chills evenly when you stir.

    !Using too little ice means you have to stir longer and over-dilute the drink.

  3. 3

    Stir steadily with the bar spoon for about 20 to 25 seconds, moving the ice smoothly around the glass. You're done when the outside of the mixing glass feels cold to the touch and there's a light frost forming.

    ~25s

    !Stirring too fast or rattling the ice chips it down and waters out the drink.

  4. 4

    Take the coupe glass out of the freezer. Set the Hawthorne strainer over the top of the mixing glass and pour the drink through the strainer into the coupe. The liquid should be clear and free of ice shards.

    !Pouring too quickly can splash the drink over the rim of the small coupe.

  5. 5

    Drop a maraschino cherry into the glass. Serve it right away while it's still cold.

Serve

Serve it up in a chilled coupe with a single cherry. Drink it soon — spirit-forward stirred drinks warm up and open up fast.

Variations

Ingredient substitutions

Each row shows what you can swap in place of an original ingredient, and how the drink changes.

Swap options for Amer Picon

  • Amer PiconTorani Amer
    Match
    Specialty availability

    Amer PiconTorani Amer: Very close to the original with similar bitter orange and gentian notes, just slightly sweeter.

  • Amer PiconAmaro Nonino
    Match
    Specialty availability

    Amer PiconAmaro Nonino: Lighter and more citrus-forward with less bitter intensity, making the drink softer overall.

  • Amer PiconCampari
    Match
    Common availability

    Amer PiconCampari: Adds more bright red bitterness and less orange depth, shifting the drink toward a drier, sharper profile.

Swap options for Rye Whiskey

  • Rye WhiskeyBourbon Whiskey
    Match
    Common availability

    Rye WhiskeyBourbon Whiskey: Sweeter and rounder with less spice, making the drink softer and less sharp on the finish.

Swap options for Maraschino Liqueur

  • Maraschino LiqueurLuxardo Maraschino
    Match
    Specialty availability

    Maraschino LiqueurLuxardo Maraschino: This is the standard brand — functionally identical to any other maraschino liqueur.

Related

Similar cocktails

Cousin drinks that share DNA with this one — each profile stands on its own.

Manhattan

Similar cocktail

Manhattan

The Manhattan uses sweet vermouth and Angostura bitters, making it richer and sweeter than the dry, bitter Brooklyn.

Match

Both are rye-driven stirred drinks, but the Brooklyn is noticeably drier and more bitter with a cherry-herbal edge the Manhattan doesn't have.

In common: spirit-forward, stirred, served up, whiskey base

Ingredients

Both share

Rye Whiskey

Only in Brooklyn

Dry Vermouth, Maraschino Liqueur, Amer Picon

Only in Manhattan

Sweet Vermouth, Angostura Bitters

Swapping sweet vermouth for dry and adding maraschino and Amer Picon turns the Manhattan's rich sweetness into the Brooklyn's lean, bitter profile.

Flavor

Shared flavors

whiskey-forward backbone, stirred and served up, warming finish

How Manhattan differs

drier, more bitter, lighter body, herbal and cherry notes

View recipe & details →

Bensonhurst

Similar cocktail

Bensonhurst

The Bensonhurst uses Cynar instead of Amer Picon, adding an artichoke-amaro earthiness instead of bitter orange.

Match

They drink very similarly, but the Bensonhurst leans earthy and vegetal where the Brooklyn leans bitter orange and herbal.

In common: spirit-forward, stirred, served up, bitter-sweet

Ingredients

Both share

Rye Whiskey, Dry Vermouth, Maraschino Liqueur

Only in Brooklyn

Amer Picon

Only in Bensonhurst

Cynar

The only difference is the amaro — Amer Picon brings bitter orange while Cynar brings earthy, vegetal bitterness.

Flavor

Shared flavors

dry and bitter backbone, cherry sweetness from maraschino, rye spice up front

How Bensonhurst differs

more earthy, less citrus, slightly heavier body

View recipe & details →

Martinez

Similar cocktail

Martinez

The Martinez is gin-based with sweet vermouth, making it softer and more aromatic than the rye-driven Brooklyn.

Match

The Martinez is softer and more aromatic with gin's botanicals, while the Brooklyn is spicier, drier, and more bitter from the rye and Amer Picon.

In common: spirit-forward, stirred, served up, bitter-sweet

Ingredients

Both share

Maraschino Liqueur

Only in Brooklyn

Rye Whiskey, Dry Vermouth, Amer Picon

Only in Martinez

Gin, Sweet Vermouth, Angostura Bitters

Different base spirit, different vermouth, different bittering agent — only the maraschino carries over between the two.

Flavor

Shared flavors

faint cherry note, bitter-sweet balance, stirred and served up

How Martinez differs

lighter and more botanical, sweeter, less spicy

View recipe & details →

History

Origin

The Brooklyn first appeared in print in the early 1900s, most notably in Jack Grohusko's 1908 'Jack's Manual'. The original called for Amer Picon, a French bitter orange liqueur that is difficult to find in the US today, which has led to widespread substitution over the years.

Era
1900s
Confidence

The original spec calls for Amer Picon, which is nearly impossible to find in the US; Torani Amer is the widely accepted substitute. Ratios vary across sources, with some using equal parts vermouth and whiskey.

Practical

Tips & pitfalls

What works at home and what to skip when making this drink.

Tips

Worth knowing before you pour

  • Amer Picon is hard to find — Torani Amer is the closest US substitute.
  • Stir with big ice to keep dilution low and the drink tight.
  • A chilled glass makes a real difference for stirred drinks served up.
  • Keep your dry vermouth in the fridge after opening.

Avoid

Common mistakes

  • Don't skip the Amer Picon or the drink loses its defining character.
  • Don't over-pour the maraschino or it will taste like cough syrup.
  • Don't shake — it clouds the drink and waters it down.